Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision		Previous revision
articles:how_to_appeal_nonconformance [2023/05/14 20:57] – [Non-Responsiveness of the Registrar] rrandallarticles:how_to_appeal_nonconformance [2024/02/08 11:53] (current) – [Preparing for a Complaint or Appeal] rrandall
Line 1: Line 1:
-====== How to Appeal a Non-conformance ======+====== How to Appeal a Nonconformance ======
 {{keywords>How to Appeal a Nonconformance}} {{keywords>How to Appeal a Nonconformance}}
 A MAJOR problem with both ISO 9001:2015 and AS 9100:2016 is the proliferation of ambiguous/nebulous/vague requirements that promote subjective interpretation and inconsistent application.    A MAJOR problem with both ISO 9001:2015 and AS 9100:2016 is the proliferation of ambiguous/nebulous/vague requirements that promote subjective interpretation and inconsistent application.   
Line 28: Line 28:
    
 While AS9104/3 obviously doesn't mandate auditors to issue 1 nonconformity per audit day, the CB in question appears to have //mistakenly// interpreted the requirement that way. While AS9104/3 obviously doesn't mandate auditors to issue 1 nonconformity per audit day, the CB in question appears to have //mistakenly// interpreted the requirement that way.
 +
 +<WRAP center round info 80%>
 +You can also "appeal" the [[articles:classifying_nonconformities|classification of a nonconformity]]. For example, you can appeal for the reclassification of a "Major" nonconformity to a "Minor" nonconformity.
 +</WRAP>
  
 ===== Preparing for a Complaint or Appeal ===== ===== Preparing for a Complaint or Appeal =====
Line 47: Line 51:
 | [[https://asrworldwide.com|American Systems Registrar (ASR)]] | [[https://asrworldwide.com/complaint-process-2]] | | [[https://asrworldwide.com|American Systems Registrar (ASR)]] | [[https://asrworldwide.com/complaint-process-2]] |
 | [[https://www.eaglecertificationgroup.com|EAGLE Certification Group]]  | [[https://www.eaglecertificationgroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/Doc-9-V18.pdf]]  | | [[https://www.eaglecertificationgroup.com|EAGLE Certification Group]]  | [[https://www.eaglecertificationgroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/Doc-9-V18.pdf]]  |
 +| [[https://www.intertek.com/certification/| Intertek]] | [[https://www.intertek.com/business-assurance/policy-statement/| Complaints & Appeals Process]] & [[https://www.intertek.com/form/products-retail-certification-body-complaints-appeals-process/|Online Complaints & Appeals Form]] |
 | [[https://www.mcnacert.com/team|Management Certification of North America (MCNA)]]  | [[https://www.mcnacert.com/team]] † | | [[https://www.mcnacert.com/team|Management Certification of North America (MCNA)]]  | [[https://www.mcnacert.com/team]] † |
 | [[https://www.nqa.com|NQA-USA]]  | [[https://www.nqa.com/en-us/clients/regulations]] ††† | | [[https://www.nqa.com|NQA-USA]]  | [[https://www.nqa.com/en-us/clients/regulations]] ††† |
Line 75: Line 80:
 ISO 17021-1:2015, sec. 9.4.7.3 \\  ISO 17021-1:2015, sec. 9.4.7.3 \\ 
 The client shall be given opportunity for questions. And diverging opinions regarding the audit findings or conclusions between the audit team and the client shall be discussed and resolved where possible. Any __diverging opinions__ that are not resolved __shall be recorded__ and referred to the certification body.</blockquote>  The client shall be given opportunity for questions. And diverging opinions regarding the audit findings or conclusions between the audit team and the client shall be discussed and resolved where possible. Any __diverging opinions__ that are not resolved __shall be recorded__ and referred to the certification body.</blockquote> 
- 
  
 Prior to the end of the audit, inform the auditor of __any__ and __all__ nonconformities that you disagree with. In many cases, invalid nonconformities are due to a CB auditor: Prior to the end of the audit, inform the auditor of __any__ and __all__ nonconformities that you disagree with. In many cases, invalid nonconformities are due to a CB auditor:
 +{{ :articles:arguing-7218071.png?direct&300|Source: https://pixabay.com/vectors/arguing-conflict-debate-different-7218071/}}
   * misunderstanding “how” the company complies with a requirement (e.g., a worker either misunderstood the question or didn’t provide a sufficient answer);   * misunderstanding “how” the company complies with a requirement (e.g., a worker either misunderstood the question or didn’t provide a sufficient answer);
   * having a strong bias toward one specific way in which a requirement must be met (when other approaches comply with the standard as well); or   * having a strong bias toward one specific way in which a requirement must be met (when other approaches comply with the standard as well); or
Line 88: Line 93:
 <WRAP centeralign>**⇒ ⇒ ⇒ IMPORTANT ⇐ ⇐ ⇐**</WRAP> <WRAP centeralign>**⇒ ⇒ ⇒ IMPORTANT ⇐ ⇐ ⇐**</WRAP>
  
-IF “diverging opinions” over the validity of a nonconformity cannot be resolved during the audit, then you should ask the auditor to record this in the audit report. If the auditor refuses to do this, then immediately following the audit, contact the CB and issue a complaint stating: +IF “diverging opinions” over the validity of a nonconformity cannot be resolved during the audit, then you should ask the auditor to record this in the audit report. If the auditor refuses to do this, then immediately following the audit, contact the CB and issue a complaint stating: \\  
-<WRAP center round box 80%> +<box 90% round blue| **Subject: Complaint**> 
-//During our audit which took place on [date(s)], there were diverging opinions regarding nonconformity number [number] that were not resolved. While we requested that the auditor (name) record these diverging opinions (in accordance with ISO 17021-1:2015, sec. 9.4.5.4 and sec. 9.4.7.3) in the audit report, the auditor failed to do so. + \\  
 +//During our audit which took place on [date(s)], there were diverging opinions regarding nonconformity number [number] that were not resolved. While we requested that the auditor record these diverging opinions (in accordance with ISO 17021-1:2015, sec. 9.4.5.4 and sec. 9.4.7.3) in the audit report, the auditor failed to do so. \\  
 + \\  
 +Please record this as a complaint against [auditor's name] for failing to comply with ISO 17021-1:2015, sec. 9.4.5.4 and sec. 9.4.7.3.// 
  
-Please record this as a complaint against [auditor's name] for failing to comply with ISO 17021-1:2015, sec. 9.4.5.4 and sec. 9.4.7.3.//  + \\   
-</WRAP>+</box>
  
 Upon completing the complaint, submit it in writing (e.g., via e-mail) to the CB (preferably within a day or two following the audit). Upon completing the complaint, submit it in writing (e.g., via e-mail) to the CB (preferably within a day or two following the audit).
Line 100: Line 108:
  
 <WRAP center round info 80%> <WRAP center round info 80%>
-I've seen a couple of auditors "dare" the client to appeal a nonconformity... claiming that if that happens, then the Accreditation Body (AB) will accompany the next auditor during their next audit - and there will be no "leniency". In one case, I witnessed a client "call" the auditors bluff and appealed the nonconformity. The nonconformity was overturned by the CB and the auditor was "counseled" regarding his "threatening" behavior toward clients. The auditor quickly changed his approach.+I've seen a couple of auditors "dare" the client to appeal a nonconformity... claiming that if that happens, then the Accreditation Body (AB) will accompany the next auditor during their next audit - and there will be no "leniency". In one case, I witnessed a client "call" the auditor's bluff and appealed the nonconformity. The nonconformity was overturned by the CB and the auditor was "counseled" regarding his "threatening" behavior toward clients. The auditor quickly changed his approach.
  
 Where an auditor demonstrates an unacceptable lack of professionalism and/or a consistent bias toward invalid or extremist interpretations, you should issue a complaint AND the CB should allow you to “refuse” scheduling that auditor for future audit activities. Where an auditor demonstrates an unacceptable lack of professionalism and/or a consistent bias toward invalid or extremist interpretations, you should issue a complaint AND the CB should allow you to “refuse” scheduling that auditor for future audit activities.