Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision		Previous revision
Next revisionBoth sides next revision
articles:how_iso_perpetuates_flawed_concepts [2023/05/17 10:01] – [Perpetuatuation of "flawed" Concepts] rrandallarticles:how_iso_perpetuates_flawed_concepts [2023/05/17 10:09] – [Quality Policy] rrandall
Line 6: Line 6:
  
 When ISO 9001 was first released, in 1987, it was based on many military standards and the philosophical approach of many so-called "Quality Gurus" of that time. Unfortunately, rather than evolve through embracing more modern concepts (e.g., Lean, Six Sigma, Lean Six Sigma), ISO 9001 has remained "stuck" in the past. The worst aspect of ISO 9001:2015 is that it perpetuates many of the flawed concepts that were promoted by Philip Crosby's motivational management approach calling for "[[articles:crosbys_church_of_zero_defects|Zero Defects]]"... ignoring the proven concepts promoted by Walter Shewhart & W. Edwards Deming. When ISO 9001 was first released, in 1987, it was based on many military standards and the philosophical approach of many so-called "Quality Gurus" of that time. Unfortunately, rather than evolve through embracing more modern concepts (e.g., Lean, Six Sigma, Lean Six Sigma), ISO 9001 has remained "stuck" in the past. The worst aspect of ISO 9001:2015 is that it perpetuates many of the flawed concepts that were promoted by Philip Crosby's motivational management approach calling for "[[articles:crosbys_church_of_zero_defects|Zero Defects]]"... ignoring the proven concepts promoted by Walter Shewhart & W. Edwards Deming.
 +
 +==== Quality Policy ====
  
 A perfect example of a //non-value added// requirement intended to support the "[[articles:crosbys_church_of_zero_defects|Zero Defects]]" motivational management approach is contained in ISO 9001 & AS91xx is sec. 5.2: \\  A perfect example of a //non-value added// requirement intended to support the "[[articles:crosbys_church_of_zero_defects|Zero Defects]]" motivational management approach is contained in ISO 9001 & AS91xx is sec. 5.2: \\ 
Line 30: Line 32:
 I've never seen a single instance of a "Quality Policy", or lack thereof, have any impact on the QMS at all.  I've never seen a single instance of a "Quality Policy", or lack thereof, have any impact on the QMS at all. 
  
-Consequently, to the educated Quality Professional, ISO 9001 is a living philosophical battleground. And the AS 9100 standard even contains contradictory requirements.+==== Quality Objectives ==== 
 + 
 +Another example of a //non-value added// requirement intended to support the "[[articles:crosbys_church_of_zero_defects|Zero Defects]]" motivational management approach is contained in ISO 9001 & AS91xx is sec. 2.2: \\  
 +<box 80% round blue|**6.2 Quality Objectives and Planning to Achieve Them**> 
 +6.2.1 The organization shall establish quality objectives at relevant functions, levels, and processes needed for the quality management system. \\  
 +The quality objectives shall: \\  
 +a. be consistent with the quality policy; \\  
 +b. be measurable; \\  
 +c. take into account applicable requirements; \\  
 +d. be relevant to conformity of products and services and to enhancement of customer satisfaction; \\  
 +e. be monitored; \\  
 +f. be communicated; \\  
 +g. be updated, as appropriate. \\  
 + \\  
 +The organization shall maintain documented information on the quality objectives. 
 +</box> 
 + 
 +The above is contrary to No. 10 of [[https://deming.org/demings-14-points-for-management/|Deming’s 14 Points for Management]]...  
 +<blockquote>//__Eliminate slogans, exhortations__, and targets for the workforce asking for zero defects and new levels of productivity. __Such exhortations__ only create adversarial relationships, as the bulk of the causes of low quality and low productivity belong to the system and thus lie beyond the power of the workforce.//</blockquote> 
 + 
 +I've never seen a single instance of a "Quality Policy", or lack thereof, have any impact on the QMS at all. 
 + 
 +Consequently, to the educated Quality Professional, ISO 9001 is a living philosophical battleground.  
 + 
 +==== AS9100 Contradictory Requirements ==== 
 + 
 +The AS 9100 standard contains at least one contradictory requirement.
  
 <box 80% round blue|**AS9100 Contradictory Requirements**> <box 80% round blue|**AS9100 Contradictory Requirements**>